Score: 10

"WELCOME BACK"

submission: LARRY episode 1

date: November 17, 2009

I really enjoyed that Jos, I admit at the end I was put off by the abrupt change from comedy to seriocomic/dramatic, but knowing that it was trying to establish the rest of the series made it easy to forgive.

Nevertheless, I loved it! The Larry character is very amusing, I love his petulant whining haha. I'm a fan of your comedic timing, that's a fact.

Looking forward to the next installment! Have you already animated ahead of this episode, or will we be waiting patiently for the next great episode to be finished?

-Swain

Score: 10

"Yesssssssssssss!!!"

submission: Pleasure Island 2

date: July 30, 2009

Thank you for reminding me why I fly out of my seat every time I see Gooseman staring at me from Front Page, Chris.

We put this on at Comicon in our hotel room and it had all of us laughing uncontrollably, though I swear I was crying with glee.

THIS, my friend, is the Gooseman I remember!

-Swain

Score: 9

"Weeeeooooooooooo"

submission: Luis C -V.S- Tom P

date: June 25, 2009

Though the human motion was kinda stiff, it felt like every punch carried a lot of impact, which is a much harder thing to do right. I like this cartoon for that reason.

-Swain

Score: 9

"Woo"

submission: EW: Matt Sucks

date: November 8, 2008

Animation's getting a lot smoother, my friend. Definite improvement over time and up to this point, so I'm impressed.

Though someone's gotta get you a better mic :D It makes the Swain sad when great conceptual setups are undercut by lines that you can only half hear. Use that Halloween contest cash and get a kickass mic, and I SWEAR you won't be disappointed.

Oh yeah, and congrats on that second place!

-Swain

Score: 9

"!!!"

submission: Rocket Crotch Halloween

date: November 4, 2008

I likes Jezza's story best, though I chuckled vigorously at Mocha's constant interruptions. Let's face it, I always love Mocha. What episode will come next, Crotchmas?

Also, the guy a few reviews below me might have had his bad reviews deleted, let's not forget about that :X

-Swain

Score: 9

"Woah"

submission: A Madness Mystery

date: September 23, 2008

That's glorious - I almost completely forgot that Blockhead's 'birthday', aka first submission to the portal, is 2 days from now :O Seems you know all our characters better than we the creators do :D

In fact, that's what I liked the most about this. Aside from Pico (who seemed more like he was just along for the ride), you really played off the individual character personalities really well. I sorta wanted to complain that the voices sounded like they could have used more emphasis by speaking louder into the microphone, but I tend to forget that not everyone has super duper microphones, and loudness can crap up the quality fast.

Great job! This one was recommended to me by Krinkels himself, and I'm glad he did. Happy madness day!

-Swain

Score: 8

"Good, but something suffered."

submission: Then I Run

date: July 20, 2008

Felt like I had to say something, because this was a very nicely and carefully created piece with just one major flaw that I couldn't get over. That flaw is the lack of any easing on any of the tweens, and I fear it really kept me from getting into it.

I dunno, it was terribly distracting to me when beautiful pieces of art jerk around on screen and then stop just as extremely, over and over. It was most noticeable during the wheat stalk scene, when, instead of swaying and bobbing, they were kind of jerking around awkwardly. I would highly recommend looking into adding some easing to your tweens. If you're not familiar with Flash's easing function, I would be happy to help you get used to it on request.

That aside, onto the good stuff. The Firth/KolBelov influence was pretty clear here. I particularly liked the color desaturation; it kept everything very bleak. Song choice worked with the visuals as well (or vice versa), and the use of FBF was very careful and added a lot to it.

Keep up the good work, and I look forward to the fruit of your improvements!

-Swain

Score: 9

"SWAIN'D"

submission: My Screen Name

date: July 10, 2008

YOTAM TODAY'S #1 HOT NEW ANIMATOR

I wanna be as brave as you and manage to submit cartoons based on all sorts of subjects, rather than being confined to one or two series. There's a music video to a song I wrote years ago that I MIGHT JUST do, thanks to you.

Also, why is Dead or Alive (the 80s band, durrr) the bad side of the internet!?

Love,
Swain

Score: 10

"Glad it's finally catching on."

submission: 2 - The Story of Khale

date: May 31, 2008

It may sound strange, but your suffering is my pleasure.

I love watching movies with long, uncut camera shots, knowing it probably took them an entire day of shooting just to get the shot right, because if one person screws up then the entire shot needs to be done again...but then what you see in the film is the fruit of all that labor. Taking that as an example, actually seeing the effort that your characters and settings resonate...it's really an experience. Independent animators are constantly in competition between the benefits of time spent to increase quality versus the risk of dragging a project on too long without adding anything fundamentaly worthwhile via that effort.

But seeing effort pay off. that's where I get the most fun out of someone's work. I really do look forward to more success from you.

Salute!

-Swain

Score: 10

"Hurray for Pico/NG Day!"

submission: Purple Sawdust

date: April 30, 2008

And a special thanks FROM The Swain <3

I still think the ending is really solid, and the colors have only improved from your last update. Well done!

-Swain